
Yesterday adage digital published a column titled “Why I Hate Social Media.” Now I know in the world o publishing headlines sell and that’s what this was intended to do. Illicit a serious response to start a conversation be it positive or negative. And at the time I’m writing this it sure has. There are some 70+posts both lambasting and praising Matt Jones in their own right.
That said, good writing evokes thought; thought should evoke discussion; discussion a hypothesis; hypothesis some type of conclusion - I know I’m simplifying the process but you get the gist. So big picture adage succeeded with its goal but still the headline to this post thoroughly rubbed me the wrong way and in turn most of the article pissed me off as well.
As I was reading I was getting madder and madder disagreeing with everything only wanting to chew it up and spit it out and give him a piece of mind —>until I finished and started to reflect upon. Is it true that what Matt was saying I agreed with on some levels? I have to say yes BUT – I just don’t outwardly agree on every single point. I hate when I think i’m going somewhere and then I get pushed back to reality ever so cleverly.
I’m going to hit on a point and then share some of the insights that the staff here sent back after I asked them to reflect and share their thoughts on this post.
My main critique is in addressing the negativities that are discussed. When Matt notes we …”should also recognize that these exceptions merely prove the dismal rule of social media right now. Because for every Amazon or Adobe, brands with genuinely good ideas to share and good stories to tell, there’s a Skittles…and Pizza Hut.” While I do agree both of those brands (and others) didn’t do social the to the best in comparison, they took a chance and attempted to play in the social space.
Who is Matt to say that their step was less than stellar. Sure they maybe didn’t wow the masses but they (like all companies) are evolving and learning in this space. One man’s test is another’s discovery down the path of enlightenment. If companies didn’t take the risk, he as well as others wouldn’t have anything to post about.
I do believe the biggest thing this article did for me is to ensure that I and the staff here look at things from a 360 degree angle. None of us have THE ANSWER. There a multitude of players with different questions and agendas to reach the mountain top. So this in turn is just one more player with a great thought provoking post that we all need to read, reflect and respond to.
With that, here are some of the staff’s thoughts on the article. Read the rest of this entry »